This is some text inside of a div block.

Fleet Hire Versus Ownership: A Detailed Comparison For Business

In this comprehensive guide, we aim to equip you with the knowledge and tools to make an informed decision about fleet hire versus ownership. We will deconstruct the financial aspects, introduce key concepts, delve into supporting research, and explore other critical facets such as risk management. 

Our goal is to help you navigate this critical decision with confidence, contributing to the sustainable growth and success of your business. So let's get started!

Why You Should Consider Fleet Hire

In the dynamic world of business, every decision counts, and making strategic choices about resource allocation can have far-reaching implications. One such decision that businesses, particularly those in sectors like logistics, transportation, construction, and delivery services, regularly grapple with is whether to hire or own their vehicle fleet.

Choosing between fleet hire and ownership is more than a simple black-and-white decision. It's a complex cost-benefit analysis that can significantly influence your business's financial health, operational efficiency, and even environmental impact. When considering this choice, it's essential not only to factor in the direct costs, such as initial investment or rental fees, but also to delve deeper into indirect expenses and economic concepts like the time value of money and discounted cash flow.

Understanding The Basic Costs

When deciding between fleet hire and ownership, it's essential to start with a comprehensive understanding of the basic costs involved. Both options come with their own set of expenses, some obvious and some more hidden. Let's delve deeper into each of these.

Fleet Total Cost Of Ownership

Initial Investment

The most apparent cost of fleet ownership is the initial purchase price of the vehicles. Depending on the size and specifications of your fleet, this can represent a significant upfront capital expenditure.

Insurance

All vehicles need insurance coverage. The costs can vary based on factors like the vehicle's make and model, its intended use, and the company's claims history.

Tax

In many jurisdictions, you'll have to pay a form of vehicle or road tax. Depending on the local regulations, this may be a flat rate, or a value based on the vehicle's emissions, value, or other factors.

Fuel

This is a significant ongoing cost. While it can vary based on the vehicle's efficiency and the current fuel prices, it's a consistent expense that needs to be budgeted for.

Maintenance

Regular services, repairs, and part replacements are all part of maintaining a fleet. While some costs can be anticipated, unexpected issues can result in hefty expenses.

Fleet Hire Costs

Rental Payments

The most apparent cost when hiring a fleet is the regular rental payments. These are typically predictable and can be easily budgeted for.

Insurance

While some hire companies like hirefleet may include insurance in their packages, in other cases, this may be an additional cost to consider.

Fuel

Just like with ownership, fuel is a significant and consistent cost to budget for when hiring a fleet.

Maintenance

Some companies like hirefleet include maintenance in their contracts, meaning you're protected from unexpected repair costs. However, it's crucial to understand what's covered in your contract and what additional costs you may be responsible for.

Hidden Costs

Downtime

When a vehicle is out of commission due to maintenance or repairs, this can represent a loss in productivity and potential revenue. With ownership, this risk is yours to bear, while with hire, the rental company often provides a replacement vehicle.

Administration

Managing a fleet involves administrative tasks like licensing, registration, managing insurance claims, and dealing with maintenance and repairs. These tasks take time and resources that might otherwise be directed towards your core business activities.

Depreciation

Vehicles lose value over time. When you own a fleet, this depreciation is a cost to your business. In contrast, with fleet hire, the hire company absorbs this cost. You can learn more about how depreciation works here.

Disposal

At the end of a vehicle's life, you'll need to dispose of it. This process can be time-consuming and expensive, especially if you're trying to sell old vehicles. In the case of fleet hire, the vehicle simply returns to the hire company at the end of the contract.

The Time Value of Money Explained

One of the fundamental principles in finance is the time value of money, which is the concept that money available today is worth more than the same amount in the future due to its potential earning capacity. This principle is crucial to understanding the financial implications of fleet hire versus ownership.

Simply put, the time value of money suggests that you'd prefer to receive £1,000 today rather than £1,000 in a year, because you could invest that £1,000 today and earn interest or returns over that year. If, for example, you could earn 5% interest per year, then your £1,000 today would become £1,050 in one year's time.

In the context of fleet management, let's say you're considering purchasing a vehicle that costs £20,000. If you pay that amount upfront, you've incurred an immediate expense. However, if you could instead hire a similar vehicle for £5,000 per year, you would still have £15,000 at the start (the £20,000 you had minus the £5,000 you spent on hiring) that could potentially be invested elsewhere in your business to generate returns.

So, even though you might end up spending the same amount of money over four years of hiring (£5,000 x 4 years = £20,000), the ability to use the majority of that money elsewhere in the early years provides an advantage from the perspective of the time value of money.

This concept becomes even more crucial when you consider the potential for unexpected vehicle-related costs, like maintenance and repairs, which can arise more frequently as a vehicle ages. If you own the vehicle, these costs are yours to bear, whereas with fleet hire, with a van rental company like hirefleet we take on these risks.

The Impact of Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)

Understanding the time value of money allows us to grasp the principle of Discounted Cash Flow (DCF). DCF is a financial model used to determine the value of an investment based on its future cash flows. By discounting these future cash flows back to their present value, we can make more informed decisions today.

In the context of fleet management, DCF can help assess the long-term financial implications of hiring vs. purchasing. It allows us to consider not only the immediate costs but also the spread of these costs over time and their respective value in today's terms.

Let's take a simple example:

Suppose you're deciding between buying a vehicle outright for £30,000 or leasing it for £7,500 per year over a 5-year term.

From a purely cash-based perspective, the total cost of leasing (£7,500 x 5 = £37,500) seems higher than buying. However, this perspective doesn't take into account the time value of money.

With a DCF analysis, we'd 'discount' each of the annual £7,500 lease payments back to today's value, using an appropriate discount rate, often the rate of return we could expect from investing that money elsewhere (let's use a conservative rate of 5%).

Here's what that might look like:

Year 1: £7,500 / (1+0.05)^1 = £7,142.86

Year 2: £7,500 / (1+0.05)^2 = £6,802.72

Year 3: £7,500 / (1+0.05)^3 = £6,478.78

Year 4: £7,500 / (1+0.05)^4 = £6,170.26

Year 5: £7,500 / (1+0.05)^5 = £5,876.44

Adding these discounted figures up gives us a total of £32,471.06.

This DCF analysis shows us that when considering the time value of money, the cost of leasing over 5 years (£32,471.06) is indeed higher than the upfront cost of buying (£30,000), but it's not as much higher as the simple cash-based perspective suggested. In other words, the future lease payments are worth less in today's money terms.

This difference could potentially be offset if the money retained in the business by leasing (instead of buying) can be used to generate a return higher than the discount rate used, adding another layer of complexity to the decision-making process.

Keep in mind, this is a simplified example, and the actual calculation would need to take into account factors such as maintenance costs, vehicle downtime, and resale value for an owned vehicle. Nonetheless, it illustrates the valuable insights DCF can provide when weighing the decision to hire or buy a fleet.

Consideration of Borrowing Costs

So far, we've looked at the time value of money and discounted cash flow, both important financial principles that can influence the decision between fleet hire and ownership. However, there's another crucial aspect to consider, especially if buying a fleet would necessitate taking out a loan - borrowing costs.

Borrowing money to finance the purchase of a vehicle fleet doesn't come free. You'll typically pay interest on any loan, and these interest payments can significantly add to the total cost of owning your fleet.

Consider the £30,000 vehicle from our previous example. Let's say you finance this purchase with a 5-year loan at an interest rate of 6% per year. Over the lifetime of the loan, you would pay about £4,680 in interest. Therefore, the total cost of the vehicle isn't just the purchase price, but also the interest you pay on the loan, bringing the total to £34,680.

When compared to the DCF cost of leasing over the same period (£32,471.06), leasing starts to look even more attractive.

But that's not all. The loan commitment also ties up your borrowing capacity. This could limit your ability to secure additional financing for other business opportunities that may arise. Moreover, loans often come with covenants or restrictions, reducing your flexibility in managing your business.

In contrast, fleet hiring can offer more financial flexibility. Since hire fees are usually treated as operational expenses, they don't tie up your capital or limit your borrowing capacity to the same extent.

However, it's important to remember that every business is unique, and so are its financial situation and borrowing needs. Therefore, considering borrowing costs should be just one part of your comprehensive analysis when deciding between fleet hire and ownership.

Research Supporting Fleet Hire

When dealing with complex financial decisions like fleet hire versus ownership, it's often beneficial to consider research and findings from experts in the field. One such study that has garnered attention was conducted by Professor Peter Cooke Professor of Automotive Management at the University of Buckingham.

Professor Cooke's research indicates that contract hire can be significantly cheaper than vehicle purchase, particularly when taking into account the discounted cash flow (DCF). His analysis, which employed a DCF rate of 15%, suggests that the long-term benefits of hiring can outweigh those of purchasing, particularly in the current economic climate.

Critics might argue that a DCF rate of 15% seems quite generous. However, even when adjusted to a more conservative figure, like 10%, the study still showed that contract hire, and long-term rental outperform purchase. This is particularly true when considering the cost of borrowing to purchase vehicles, as previously discussed.

While every business's circumstances will differ, Professor Cooke's research does underscore the potential financial advantages of fleet hire. It suggests that we must consider more than just the upfront or apparent costs when comparing hiring and buying options.

Furthermore, this research complements the notion that tying up capital in a depreciating asset like a vehicle may not be the most financially advantageous strategy. Instead, businesses could potentially gain more by investing that capital elsewhere and opting for vehicle hire.

The Psychological Aspect of Ownership vs Hire

When discussing the hire vs ownership debate, it's crucial to address not only the financial considerations but also the psychological factors that can influence this decision. These are the intangible elements that can play a significant role in how comfortable a business owner feels with their choice.

Sense of Control

Ownership often brings with it a sense of control and permanence. This can manifest as a feeling of stability, the ability to make decisions about the use and treatment of the vehicle without needing to consult a rental company or abide by their terms and conditions. Some business owners find this control over their assets to be a major advantage of ownership.

Freedom and Flexibility

On the other hand, hiring provides a level of freedom and flexibility that ownership cannot match. Companies can scale their fleet up or down based on their current needs without worrying about selling or buying vehicles. This can be particularly beneficial for businesses with fluctuating demand or those in a growth phase where needs might change quickly.

Ease and Peace of Mind

Hiring a fleet also brings peace of mind when it comes to maintenance and repairs. With rental agreements such as the ones you can find at hirefleet, the hiring company takes care of routine maintenance and repairs, reducing the business owner's mental load and allowing them to focus on their core business operations. This can also reduce the stress and unpredictability associated with potential repair costs and vehicle downtime.

Perceived Prestige

Lastly, there's the psychological aspect of prestige. Some business owners may feel that owning their fleet contributes to the image of a successful, stable business. In contrast, others might view the ability to frequently update their fleet with the latest models through hiring as a way to project an image of being a cutting-edge, adaptable company.

Risk Management

Risk management is an integral part of any business strategy, and the decision between fleet hire and ownership is no exception. By choosing to hire a fleet, businesses can manage and mitigate several key risks associated with vehicle ownership.

Predictability of Costs

One of the main advantages of fleet hire is the predictability of costs. When you hire a fleet, your costs are typically set out in the contract, providing a clear overview of your financial commitment for the term of the hire. This can help in budgeting and cash flow management, reducing the risk of unexpected expenses that can strain your finances.

On the contrary, owning a fleet can come with unpredictable costs. These can range from unscheduled maintenance and repairs to unexpected downtime due to vehicle issues. While it's possible to budget for routine maintenance, unexpected repairs can often come at a high cost, both financially and in terms of disrupted operations.

Exposure to Used Vehicle Market

Ownership also exposes businesses to the volatility of the used vehicle market. When it's time to sell your vehicles, the resale value can be unpredictable, impacted by factors such as market demand, the condition of the vehicle, and technological advancements.

Fleet hire alleviates this risk, as the responsibility of selling the vehicle at the end of its life cycle rests with the hire company. This means businesses hiring their fleet can avoid the uncertainties and potential financial losses related to the resale of vehicles.

Flexibility and Adaptability

Fleet hire also offers the advantage of flexibility, allowing businesses to adapt to changes in demand or operational requirements. This is particularly beneficial in uncertain times or volatile markets where business needs can change rapidly.

In conclusion, while there are risks associated with both fleet hire and ownership, hiring a fleet can offer a range of risk management benefits. However, each business is unique, and it's important to consider these factors in light of your own risk tolerance and business needs when making your decision.

Conclusion

Choosing between fleet hire and ownership is a significant decision, requiring a deep understanding of not just the obvious costs, but also the less apparent ones. It necessitates an evaluation of various financial, psychological and risk management factors to ensure the choice aligns with your business needs and objectives.

Throughout this discussion, we've explored the concept of the time value of money, the impact of Discounted Cash Flow (DCF), and the importance of considering borrowing costs. We've found that the decision is not as simple as comparing upfront costs. Instead, a more sophisticated financial analysis may favour fleet hire due to factors such as DCF and potential returns on alternative investments.

From a psychological perspective, ownership may bring feelings of control and prestige, while hiring offers freedom, flexibility, and peace of mind from maintenance worries. 

Lastly, risk management considerations also come into play. Fleet hire provides more predictable costs and less exposure to the used vehicle market, offering stability in budgeting and planning.

In the end, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Your decision should be based on a comprehensive understanding of these factors, tailored to your unique business circumstances and future projections. Therefore, it's highly recommended to conduct a thorough cost analysis that goes beyond the surface, taking into account all the variables that impact the total cost of ownership or hire.

Remember, the decision you make today will shape your fleet operations for years to come. Make sure it's a well-informed one.

Need Further Support With Your Decision?

Throughout this discussion, our aim has been to equip you with the insights and understanding necessary to make an informed decision between fleet hire and ownership. Remember, you don't have to navigate these complex considerations alone.

At hirefleet, we're here to support you every step of the way. We understand that every business is unique, and a decision of this magnitude deserves a personalised, meticulous approach. 

Our team is ready and eager to help you evaluate your specific needs, analyse potential cost implications, and ultimately determine whether fleet hire or ownership aligns best with your business objectives.

We believe in empowering businesses with knowledge and the right resources. If you still have questions, or if you'd like a helping hand as you navigate this important decision, don't hesitate to get in touch.

It is not just about making a choice - it's about making the right choice for your business. And with hirefleet by your side, you can rest assured that you're making an informed decision backed by expert insight and personalised advice.

Let us be your partner in this journey. Contact hirefleet today, and let's work together to discover the fleet solution that drives your business forward.

hirefleet

Passionate reader | People person | The one behind All Bad jokes
11
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Ranger, Toyota Hilux
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
12
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Transit Custom, VW Transporter
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
15
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Transit, Citroen Relay
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
13
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Transit, Citroen Relay
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
5
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
XLWB Ford Transit, Peugeot Boxer Dropside
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
2
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
XLWB Ford Transit, Peugeot Boxer Dropside or similar
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
8
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
XLWB Ford Transit, Citroen Relay
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
9
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
XLWB Ford Transit, Peugeot Boxer Dropside or similar
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
1
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
LWB Ford Transit, Mercedes Sprinter
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
6
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Transit, Iveco Daily Luton
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
7
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
LWB Ford Transit Custom, VW Transporter
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
10
Tail Lift
︁
Manual Transmission
sold
Payload:
F405
mm
Load Length:
F407
mm
Load Width:
F409
mm
Load Height:
F411
mm
Fuel Consumption:
-
mpg
Ford Transit Connect, Citroen Berlingo
or similar
£
(2 days)
Book now
Quick news links
Read more
You might also be interested in these
News
The Benefits of Minibus Hire for Event Planners

Discover the multifaceted benefits of minibus hire for event planners in our in-depth guide. Whether it's the convenience and togetherness for wedding parties or the professional appeal for corporate events, minibus rental offers a practical and cost-effective solution.

With options ranging from 6 seater minibus hire to 9 seater minibus hire, this guide delves into how a rental minibus enhances every event, ensuring comfort, safety, and a memorable experience for all attendees.

News
True Cost of Moving House 2023

Looking to move home but unsure about exactly how much it will cost you in 2023? Don’t worry, we will break down the key variables, costs, and considerations. 

We will also share with you how to save money when moving house by hiring a luton removal van instead of paying over the odds for a removal company.

News
Changes To Highway Code

There have been 3 new rules introduced for road user hierarchy. The new concept for these rules’ centres around the differing levels of risk for road users in the event of a collision. The hierarchy considers the likelihood of the road user to be injured in the event of a collision and places them at most risk and at the top of the hierarchy. This sets the precedent that van drivers have an increase in responsibility within the context of vans interacting with other road users, as in the event of a collision they are less likely to come out worse than a cyclist, pedestrian, or motorcyclist. Pedestrians and cyclists would be an example of road users at the highest risk during a collision.

News
Team Building & Corporate Retreats with Self Drive Minibus Hire

Delve into the transformative potential of self-drive minibus hire for corporate retreats and team-building adventures. With hirefleet's corporate minibus hire services, planning a getaway that strengthens team bonds and fosters a collaborative spirit has never been easier.

We highlight top destinations that are perfect for such occasions, demonstrating how minibus hire can make the journey as enriching as the destination itself. Discover the ease and flexibility of coordinating a retreat that will leave lasting memories and promot3e a positive workplace culture.

Stay up to date with our latest self drive van hire options and special offers!
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Your local hirefleet facilities are based in Bawtry, conveniently located on the borders of Yorkshire, Nottinghamshire & Lincolnshire. With just a 3 minute drive to the A1(M) J34 - Blyth Services, you'll be on the road in no time

To buy quality used vans visit Salesfleet.co.uk